Acclaimed actress Cynthia Erivo has ignited a firestorm of reaction after being cast as Jesus in the upcoming Hollywood Bowl production of Jesus Christ Superstar. This bold reimagining of the classic rock opera has generated both applause and strong condemnation.
Backlash from Critics
Some conservative Christians labeled the casting “blasphemous,” even describing Erivo’s appearance—bald head, long fingernails, and crown of thorns—as “demonic” CBNPremier Christian News. Kevin Sorbo called the portrayal “demonic,” while others echoed that sentiment on social media AM 1440 KYCR.
Defense from Creators & Supporters
Tim Rice, the musical’s co-lyricist, defended the casting as “quite exciting,” applauding Erivo’s talent and pointing out that Jesus has historically been portrayed in many ways WhatsOnStage.com –. Adam Lambert—playing Judas—added that the musical is meant to challenge societal expectations and that Jesus’ message transcends gender The Express TribuneSportskeeda.
Erivo’s Response
Erivo addressed the controversy with grace and humor, noting, “It’s a musical, the gayest place on Earth… You can’t please everyone,” and encouraged critics to experience the production before passing judgment TheWrapEW.com.
Theological Perspective
Dr. Jonny Rowlands, a theology lecturer, emphasized that feminine depictions of Christ have precedent in scripture (e.g., Jesus likened to a mother hen, imagery in Revelation). He argued that dismissing such portrayals is inconsistent with biblical nuance The Times.
Stage Reception
The production, which ran August 1–3, earned critical acclaim—particularly for Erivo’s emotionally charged performance in “Gethsemane,” which prompted a standing ovation at the Hollywood Bowl The Guardian.
Summary of Reactions
| Perspective | Voice or Response |
|---|---|
| Outrage | Critics decry the casting as “blasphemous” or “demonic.” |
| Artistic Defense | Creators and cast emphasize innovation and intent to challenge norms. |
| Performer’s View | Erivo invites audiences to judge her performance firsthand. |
| Theological Insight | Scripture supports non-literal, gender-fluid imagery of Christ. |
| Critical Acclaim | Reviewers praise the emotional power of the production. |
